Monday 4 April 2011

Not a pretty picture today...


News of natural disasters all over the world seem to have quietened down recently, and, after a slew of articles, Facebook updates, tweets, and video-sharing – especially from tech-savvy Japan) of how the earthquakes and tsunamis have affected people on the ground, now I’ve only got my profile picbadge on FB as a reminder that Japan ever had a tsunami.

Just imagine…

Friend: ‘Wow, what a lovely beachfront home you have! It must be soothing to hear the waves crashing upon the shore…’
Owner (proudly): ‘Yes, we saved for many years to move here. It’s been a huge sacrifice, but worthwhile.’
Along comes a wave.
Tsunami: ‘ARHM…..gulp!’
Spits out debris.

And what about quake-hit Haiti, China, New Zealand, Myanmar and Thailand? Floods in Brisbane, etc etc… Does anyone know of an ‘Act for our world’ picbadge??

It’s impossible to describe the impact of all those disasters here, and what do I know anyway? Typing away in my comfy little study, knowing that everyone I care about is safe...

The closest I’ve come to flooding was when the ceiling in my bedroom collapsed many years ago. My family and I got home to find rainwater gushing down the stairs like whitewater rapids. I can’t recall how we got all that water out, but I guess it was a case of opening all the doors, mopping and wringing frantically to help things along a bit. There was quite a long process of trying to save what we could – I remember fanning out pages of exercise books to dry them out and sorting through sodden clothes to save those that were still ok – which we did over several days after work or school.

It felt bad enough at the time, but I’d nearly forgotten about it, so it can’t have been that terrible. Multiply those days spent cleaning up to months or years, recall the sadness when anyone I’ve ever loved has died, and that might get me just a little closer to understanding how the Japanese and other disaster-stricken people have felt lately.

Everything they had before suddenly counts for nothing, with families, homes and jobs lost. This is the ultimate reminder that nature is a great leveller, but, despite the tragedies, it is heartening to see and hear about people coming together to overcome hardship. 

It’s difficult to conceive of this magnitude without generalising everything to the point where it feels as unreal as some Hollywood disaster movie. I must admit that I probably wouldn’t be moved to do anything if not for the many pictures of individuals...parents, spouses, someone's best friend, uncle, niece or child, trying to place where their homes once stood and grieving for their lost ones.

It’s inspired me to think of how I could help, and this is the best I've come up with:

I’d been working on a pair of William and Kate dolls to commemorate the Royal Wedding. At first, I saw this as a way to stretch myself, and see how well I could represent one of the most internationally recognised couples. Now I hope that publicity generated by the most widely broadcasted event this year can help raise funds for people who could really use it.

So when Will and Kate are ready in the next few days, they’ll be listed on an eBay auction in the run-up to April 29th. I hope to have some more affordable cards made for sale too, so anyone can contribute, whatever your budget.

All proceeds from these sales will go towards disaster relief. I’ll post a receipt on my website and Facebook page afterwards so you can check back and see where the money’s gone. So please help as much as you can. Bid on my dolls if you like them, buy a card, tell everyone you know and send them a link, especially anyone you know who collects Royal memorabilia.

Oh, and here’s another thing…

I must admit that I’ve become quite cynical of charities lately. I have so many doubts. How do I know that the money helps those who really need it? How much of my money will get to them? There’re so many charities these days, are they for real or are people just taking advantage of some loophole in the law? Our phone rings several times a day, always from some charity I’d never heard of, asking if I wouldn’t like to bring some joy to a child / elderly person / refugee / insert other pitiful image for only £2 a month / only a one-off £8 … you get the idea. When I stopped picking up in the day, they starting phoning at night or came knocking on our door. It makes me think a charity is just another commercial enterprise, and their sales reps are even more annoying and harder to get rid of because their pitch is designed to manipulate you into feeling like a selfish, heartless wretch. 

So many people I know are also publicising their own charitable endeavours. I think it’s great to support them, and if my friends think a cause is worthwhile, then I like to trust their judgement. But £5 or £10 here and there can quickly eat into your own budget.

When someone recently blogged this article, 'Don't donate money to Japan' , I understood the writer’s point immediately and believe it would hit a nerve with many of you before you’d even read it. So I wouldn’t be surprised if you are also feeling a bit jaded and have got those filters on.

I'm sure most people wish to help in any way they can. I do too, but not without knowing that it’ll go to the right people. I don’t think buying a Big Issue from my local seller goes very far, but at least it helps her directly. Donating unused items to charity isn’t much of a sacrifice either, but the shops ask for them, so why not. I’m very uncomfortable with the knowledge that well-meant donations might be spent on costly marketing campaigns, over-generous salaries, exploitative reimbursement claims or commissions for persistent cold-callers I mean, why else would someone tolerate countless refusals all day long? How many of the best marketing executives would work at a charity for less? How much of it goes on snazzy posters and 'branding'?

I know we need to make a balanced judgement on these matters, so I hope I’ve not been too cynical there. I’d be over the moon for you to post a link to any sincere articles or provide information that help answer these questions. Your donations will go to the Red Cross, as I hope they’ll allocate the funds to whoever needs it most, but please chime in if you think you can help me make a more informed choice.

Thank you for your support.

4 comments:

Anonymous said...

I'm a cynic and I used to hate the thought that my donations might be going towards someone's salary or some fiddly admin stuff instead of the suffering people the money was intended for. But I have to say that every person I've met who actually works for a charity is passionate about the cause, and usually underpaid and overworked into the bargain. it isn't fair to expect that they live on love and fresh air, so so be it if my donations pay them to do the dirty work that I can't or won't do myself. At the end of the day, the charity's beneficiaries will be helped one way or another.

SessMuph

Tracy Su said...

Yup, fiddly admin stuff...waste of resources in many organisations, so I had no reason to believe it was any different in charities. I think I pretty much came to the same conclusion as you, though I don't know anyone who works for a charity. I don't expect charity workers to live on love, neither am I noble myself, so I'll just give them the money and let them do what they know best.

PT said...

Underpaid charity workers are ok as far as I am concern, but not if they demand golden taps in their private loos and 1st class air travel! Or outsource the dirty work to others at market or higher than market rates!

Tracy Su said...

I doubt they go that far...but higher than market rates could be ok if the companies outsourced to do a better job than they do themselves, I think.